The Bad Economy Offers An Opportunity To Secure Your Job

As hard as the present economy is negatively impacting the country, the situation is destined to get worse because policy-driven unemployment and coming inflation will not run their course for some time. Then, we must face the reality that the private club and daily fee golf economies (not the municipal market because it is government funded) will be hit significantly harder than the balance of America because:

1. The Obama administration is committed to “redistributing” wealth out of America’s achieving class; i.e., the core of the country’s private club membership community. This is a direct assault on every private club’s membership base.

2. The first reality check for the country’s private golf club community still lies ahead because this year’s member dues were solicited last fall before the national economy started to seriously decline. Therefore, when 2010 member dues are solicited this fall (and this process is repeated next year for 2011 dues) private clubs and daily fee courses could be looking at a level of economic pressure not seen since WWII.

Should the economy continue to unravel as economists and the above realities suggest it might, as many as 5000 superintendents at every salary level (roughly one in three) will face the prospect of being replaced in their jobs by lowered salaried people over the next several years. Several recent national polls indicate that roughly 72% of the country’s golf course superintendents presently feel insecure in their jobs.

All of the above commentary is not intended to frighten you. Rather, it is intended to educate the profession to the reality you face because the national TV and news print media have a tendency to paint the national economy in a far more positive light than circumstances warrant. As difficult as the present economic circumstance might seem, you should not let the threat of a job loss discourage you because there are definitive steps you can take to help secure your job in the worst of economies. For example:

1.   Do not await news. Superintendents who sit passively by hoping for the best are likely to get hurt. News that you wait to come to you invariably will be bad news.

Borrowing on the premise that the “best defense is often a good offense” and the use of personal diplomacy, take the lead…

2.   Take the initiative. Borrowing on the premise that the “best defense is often a good offense” and the use of personal diplomacy, take the lead (be timely) to reach a mutual understanding with your employer relative to what budget cuts will be needed from year to year to keep pace with a declining economy – without undermining the fundamental quality of the golf course. Be prepared to cut operating budgets up to +/- 30% over several years, if necessary.

Then, once circumstances have dictated it is time to cut budgets, don’t hesitate to volunteer to take the same percentage cut in salary as is being mandated for the department’s operating budget. Clearly, it is better to have a job at roughly 75% to 80% of a former peak salary than have no job at all.  Major employee unions utilize this wage-cutting practice all the time to keep jobs.

You will have to prove yourself all over again in the current economic climate if you want to secure your job…”

With the two goals of a reduced operating budget and a discounted superintendent’s salary in hand, employers will look favorably toward retaining the known effectiveness of their golf course superintendent instead of hiring a less proven commodity.

3. Do not push for a written contract in these difficult times unless it is otherwise offered because this could unsettle things; rather, accept what is being offered; i.e., standard year-to-year, or multi-year verbal agreements that will allow you the opportunity to prove yourself anew in today’s very challenging times.

Yes, it will all get down to the single thought that you will have to prove yourself all over again in today’s market if you want to secure your job. Once this premise is accepted, you will be in a position to “earn” new job security.

4. When written contracts are once again in vogue (and this day will come sooner than many think), include the concept of binding arbitration within the contract’s termination clause – as suggested in my June 18th blog entitled, “Binding Arbitration.”

I would like to be wrong about the high level of concern the country and golf course superintendents will continue facing, but this may not be the case. Nevertheless, it is far better to prepare for and be able to deal with the worst (even if the worst never comes) than not to prepare at all and suffer the debilitating consequences. Always remember – you are selling the game’s most precious commodity: yourselves. God speed.

Superintendents, want to help your assistant(s) on their career path? Print out these Career Corner posts and responses on an ongoing basis and assemble them in a hard copy binder for your assistants and crew.

6 Responses to “The Bad Economy Offers An Opportunity To Secure Your Job”

  • Jim,

    I think you have hit the nail on the head — we agree politcally too. However, golf course superintendents are a resilient lot — even in the 1930’s those who provided value did OK.

    As you have said, everyone will have to prove themselves — superintendents are accustomed to doing that everyday no matter where the are working in this world.

    Best regards,

    Jim

    [Reply]

    Jim McLoughlin Reply:

    JIM:

    No question superintendents have the ability to prove themselves – but in this instance they have to know that they will have to prove themselves over again after having done so earlier at their present jobs.

    [Reply]

  • Gregory:

    Jim:
    There may finally be some “justice” in our little corner of the world. Those who have traditionally gotten the big jobs have really just been lucky, inexperienced people in their 20’s..When unable to blow all the money they can, they may not succeed and those who have struggled all these years may finally get the opportunity to show what real knowledge and experience can bring to a club looking for more value in a superintendent. I know many who could produce a better product for half the budget of some of the extravagant operations out there. I’m talking a 6 to 700k budget over a 1.3 or 1.5 mil budget..That’s plenty of money for those who are producing a great product for 3 to 400k.
    But those 1.2 to 1.5 guys cry when they get cut to 900k. So let them cry..let them whine..they don’t know what real hardship is…Maybe they’ll pack up their toys and go home..After all they should have saved up enough of their big salaries to retire by now anyway..

    [Reply]

    Jim McLoughlin Reply:

    GREGORY:

    You are wrong when you make the blanket statement that higher salaried superintendents got their jobs because they were “lucky.” Rather, they have “earned” their way to the top like everyone else; i.e., starting down the line and out-competing 60 to 100-plus candidates for each job advancement along the way.

    YES – a few top salaried superintendents “coast” on the job but they almost always pay the price of losing their jobs when they shouldn’t. YES – a good number of lowered salaried superintendents can do a better job than some higher salaried superintendents and they will get the opportunity to fight their way to the top just like the men and women before them did. This is what life is all about.

    Superintendents don’t “cry” when faced with budget cuts. You are confusing the natural “venting” and “soul-searching” process superintendents must go through to clear their heads before re-committing to maintaining the quality of their golf courses with less money. This is a necessary and healthy process.

    Do well.

    [Reply]

  • David Gourlay:

    Jim,

    An excellent article! Those Superintendents that are in tune with their facility will realize the steps needed to secure their position at the club. This is the first time in my career of over 30 years that I can remember that taking a salary cut to help operations is an option to explore. It is indeed interesting and most likely scary for those that may need to consider this option. On a side note, I have reduced my salary at our facility this year and in turn was able to negiotate a life time Founders Golf Membership for myself and family. This turned out to be a win win situation.

    [Reply]

  • victor m navarrete:

    Jim,

    Again, it is a person like you who continues to have the ability to make sensible decisions and judgments based on personal knowledge and experience. Thank you. Also I could not agree more with David Gourlay’s point of view.
    You realize when you play golf you need to be in tune and focus when you step on the tee because your first stroke will put you in the position you want to be for your next shot. David you are in the right position and that is what we all should be. As David wrote, a win, win situation. I also like to mention what Mr. Chris Carson mentioned at the winter convention: the perks (a benefit given to an employee in addition to a salary, e.g. the use of a car or membership in a club) are tools, use them. Good luck to all.

    [Reply]

Leave a Reply

Presented by...
VinylGuard Golf... Renew and Protect Rake Handles, Flagsticks, Stakes and Posts
Recent Comments
  • Jim McLoughlin: PETER: Thank you for reminding me that partnerships are a high risk way of doing business because 75%...
  • Peter McCormick: Jim – Your post is a case study in how I conceived and developed TurfNet back in early 1994....
  • Jim Prusa: Jim, Nice piece here. It actually has universal application fro everyone in golf course management —...
  • Steve Spuhler: Can you come up with something like this for equipment techs and managers?
  • John Cummings: Jim, What a great tool. I hope people make use of it.
Polls

Are you exploring second career options now?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...