Archive for November, 2009
A knowledgeable source with Audubon credentials informed me that there are now five golf courses that are pesticide-free. He did not specify if these five were located in Canada, the North American continent or indeed the world. I assume the latter and in that case I have played two of them: A 9-holer in Katmandu, Nepal with sand greens and another in the interior of New Zealand, also 9 holes and grazed by 489 sheep and fenced in greens. At the latter, the stench of sheep dung was so strong and omni-present that I concluded it had fungicidal properties that made spraying redundant. Since my visit, the greens in Kathmandu have been grassed.
I have played two of them: A 9-holer in Katmandu, Nepal with sand greens and another in the interior of New Zealand, also 9 holes and grazed by 489 sheep and fenced in greens…
There are parts of Canada on both east and west coast where the summertime highs rarely exceed 80° F. In fact I have heard it said that in Newfoundland the fog rarely lifts. Some years ago I helped built a green in Labrador during mid-June and we had to clear the snow before we could do the shaping. In southern Ontario our conditions are similar to American Great Lake states: It gets hot and humid for about 100 days during the summer, a time to test the mettle of the keepers of the green.
As you already know, the provinces of Ontario and Quebec prohibit the use of pesticides for cosmetic purposes with the stipulation that golf courses are (temporarily) exempt. Now the tiny province of Prince Edward Island in the chilly Gulf of St. Lawrence is about to follow suit. That will make it three out of ten provinces with such policies. Other left leaning provinces such as Manitoba, British Columbia and Nova Scotia are sure to fall in step. I predict that the golf course exemption will be removed a few years hence.
Now lets look at the implications of a worst-case scenario: A total ban on pesticides on Canada’s golf courses. Broadleaf weeds such as clover, dandelions, plantain, etc., are not really a problem on fairways tees and greens because such areas are fertilized intensively and weeds generally can’t compete in the vigorous grass sward.
The roughs are another matter. Golfers will have to learn to tolerate a few weeds in those areas. But what about the stands of pure fescue in “native” areas so heralded by the Audubon Society? Some of my best friends now spray the fescue on a regular basis. Without pesticides, they won’t look so pretty when interspersed with thistles, milkweed and goldenrod.
Our major fungus-related problems are snow mold/winterkill from coast to coast and Dollar Spot in the Great Lakes region. While I was an active superintendent I often omitted preventative sprays for snowmold for budgetary reasons and with no ill effects most of the time.
Dollar Spot is another matter. Some superintendents grow DS-resistant bentgrass varieties and others include fescues in their fairway mix and raise the height of cut. But when nighttime lows rise above 70F for any length of time, disease activity increases exponentially. Without treatment the grass will suffer and may even become unplayable, especially on greens.
As for insects, they seem to be a cyclical problem. Some years you get them and some years you don’t. We can live with that.
In many ways we superintendents have promoted the use of pesticides to excess as a result of our maintenance practices. Whatever happened to the good old days when greens were cut at .250 inches and fairways at a full inch? Chemical sprays were a rarity and a minor budgetary item. The introduction of the stimp meter changed all that. We have tipped the scales of sanity and only have ourselves to blame. As one nameless superintendent said: “If I could ignore the top 5% of my golfers — the single digit players — I could reduce my maintenance budget 20%”. So I warn my American colleagues that what’s happening north of the border may eventually find adherents to the South, as has already happened in California. Remember healthcare! It’s only a matter of time.